CHRIS COOPER'S BLOG - infrequent forays into fun, freedom, fysics and filosophy...

Remove the numerals from the following to contact me directly:


<< current

Liberty links
... feel free

David Friedman
Transport Blog
Freedom and Whisky
Natalie Solent
Biased BBC
The Liberty Log
Brian's EDUCATION Blog

The world in a grey brick
... for the Psion 5mx, greatest of PDAs
Psion Place
Phil Spencer's Psion Page
Psion pages of Sergio Alisi
Huub Linthorst's programs
TuCows EPOC site
Pascal Nicolas' freeware
Paul Dunkel's repair guide

The human mind
... evidence for its existence
Human Nature Review
Richard Dawkins
Steven Pinker

Data hygiene
... the truth is in here

Statistical Assessment Service
Urban Legends Archive
Number 2 Pencil

A foreign country
... my past, where they do things differently

Imperial College Physics class of '66
Peter Symonds email directory
Peter Symonds Unofficial Nostalgia Corner

Blogosophical Investigations
Friday, February 07, 2003  

Is the space junk theory just space junk?

Interesting story on the Columbia disaster investigation from Steve Milloy in his FoxNews column:

NASA is reconsidering whether tank foam debris caused the Columbia disaster. That’s quite a shift from days earlier when the foam was the "leading candidate" -- an explanation that quickly became embarrassing. … Until 1997, Columbia’s external fuel tanks were insulated with a Freon-based foam. Freon is a chlorofluorocarbon (CFC) supposedly linked with ozone depletion and phased out of widespread use under the international treaty known as the Montreal Protocol.

Despite that
[ugh! They say this in the States?] the Freon-based foam worked well and that an exemption from the CFC phase-out could have been obtained, NASA succumbed to political correctness. The agency substituted an allegedly more eco-friendly foam for the Freon-based foam.

NASA says computer modeling fails to show how foam insulation striking the thermal tiles could do enough damage to cause catastrophe -- apparently ignoring that
[Aargh! Another one!] flaking foam substantially penetrated thermal tiles on an earlier flight.

NASA has even offered up the ultimate exculpatory theory -- that space junk or even a meteor could have hit the wing and damaged the thermal tiles.

The investigation into what happened to Columbia needs to be turned over to a truly independent and qualified commission -- and before the evidentiary trail starts to disappear.

A pity Richard Feynman isn't still around to do the job, as he did on the Challenger enquiry.

11:49 AM

Comments: Post a Comment
This page is powered by Blogger.